That’s not what the text says… It says Bernie is telling him to better communicate his reasoning.
His reasoning has been perfectly well communicated, the people calling him anti-semitic are acting in bad faith and their is no critism of Israel they wouldn’t call anti-semitic. And Sanders knows this but is playing along anyway
Bernie is telling him to not criticize Israel because that is antisemitic.
this interchange is bonkers because this is the definition of antisemitic now according to the american government which is using it to justify all sorts of horrible actions.
No he isn’t. He is saying to make sure you are clear about why you are criticizing Israel so it doesn’t get interpreted as antisemitic.
Bernie is spreading anti Palestinian genocidal blood libel against Zohran and you are pretending he’s helping
That’s just obviously incorrect. Even the evidence you just posted and highlighted contradicts your conclusion. You’re being willfully ignorant at this point.
My post perfectly supports my claim.
Removed by mod
The Israel lobby accuses Joe Biden of being Hamas. What is your point?
Interpreting it THAT poorly is as unhinged as thinking criticizing Israel makes someone antisemitic
What does this mean?
“They will twist your words. Make them untwistable”
“Watch your phrasing, Israel and the media will take anything out of context”
Are you sure you know who Bernie Sanders is
If you think any of this should be said to Zohran Mamdani:
Are you sure you know who Zohran mamdani is?
Really not sure what the point of your ire is here. And you’re kind of coming off like an ass.
AIPAC and the people they influence are notorious for twisting and misrepresenting rhetoric that’s even slightly critical of the Israeli government. It pays to be extremely deliberate and careful when speaking publicly on those topics. You and I may understand the nuance of Mamdani’s position, but (to be blunt) a lot of more stupid and/or less engaged voters on NYC won’t necessarily have the same reaction. You’ll probably deride me as a “centrist” for saying this, but to ignore the propagandistic influence that AIPAC exerts is essentially an unforced error. So, yes, it is a absolutely good and correct to call out Bibi’s genocidal campaign, but it is a way better idea to do that in a specific, careful, and nuanced fashion, in the interest of minimizing AIPAC’s ability to twist the words into a weapon against him.
This line very specifically implies that Zohran has crossed the line in the past and does not make the correct distinction.
Removed by mod
So you don’t know and are just trolling.
Nice try. Bernie is very critical of Israels actions himself but don’t take my word for it, since you can’t be bothered looking it up yourself befor posting misinformation, here is his own statement about the matter: www.sanders.senate.gov/press-releases/news-sanders-statement-on-israel-palestine-and-growing-humanitarian-disaster/
Sanders has pretty consistently tried to blame it all on Netanyahu specifically while letting Israel as a whole off the hook. He’s also still a genocide denier
While it is true Sanders has actually dared to criticize Israel repeatedly. There are lines he will not cross, accusations he will not make and things he will not do.
He is the most leftward of the USA senators, which is to say he is a centralist elsewhere; and the OP is all about him doing centralist things: a balancing act
Lastly, Hamas has been very clear, both before its barbaric attack on October 7th and after that attack, that their goal is perpetual warfare and the destruction of Israel. Just last week a spokesman for Hamas, Mr. Taher El-Nounou, told the New York Times, “I hope that the state of war with Israel will become permanent on all the borders, and that the Arab world will stand with us.” I am not quite sure how you negotiate a ceasefire with a terrorist organization that is dedicated to perpetual war.
Holy YIKES at least get a more recent quote instead of “I oppose a ceasefire and want all Palestinians to be killed” Sanders.
Bernie has criticize Israel in the past. He’s saying to make sure not to say anything that could be taken out of context by a bad actor.
anything that could be taken out of context by a bad actor.
So, anything
Do you know who Zohran Mamdani?
It’s a complex issue Bernie is alluding to. There are a lot of Jewish people who think of Israel of sort of “Their place” in the world where they are centered and the controlling stake of culture. People who are raised to think this way feel critism towards the place as an attack on their Jewishness. Those feelings can override and get in the way of treating Isreal as a country, with a political agenda and make it feel as though it were a criticism of Jewish people.
You know that whole “facts don’t care about your feelings” thing the right gets on about? It’s actually backwards. Feelings do not care about facts and if you don’t adequately explain your purpose you can make people feel victimized even when they aren’t. Jewish people who feel victimized by critism of Israel are responding to a mix of cultural programming because the idea of Israel is their security blanket. Problem is the security blanket isn’t actually securing them from anything, it was just a tool to soothe anxieties about having a place to retreat to free of persecution… and now that the security blanket has been proven to be woven out of asbestos and warcrimes the trauma of prying peoples attachment from it is causing damage amongst a historically persecuted group. This is Bernie’s reminder - to be sensitive to the process of individual trauma while detangling them from the genocidal regime it’s emotionally fuzed to.
It’s not complex at all. It’s Nazi-like settler colonialism.
And Zohran already very clearly seperates Zionism and Judaism. Bernie is concern trolling. As is anyone pretending he has a valid point.
Not saying Israel is complex. Dealing with the victims of the propaganda is complex.
Compassion isn’t just good praxis, people who fall back on feeling victimized double down on whatever their base investment is. If you want people to accept facts and actually change their minds you have to engage the person’s feelings first.
Dealing with the propagand is complex and Zohran is doing an amazing job at it. Bernie is smearing him with blood libel here pretending he isn’t.
Go away, old man
you don’t mess with the Zohran
Leading every statement on Israel with “now, keep in mind, in not being antisemitic… but…” Is a good way to sound antisemitic.
not let himself seem like he’s minimizing the fear of Jews in New York and elsewhere feel from the threat of hate against them.
Yes, Mamdani should absolutely not minimize the fears of Jews, for many Jews fear being lumped in and associated with the hate-group movement known as Zionism. It is important that he make a clear statement on the distinction that Jews are not Zionists (not by default, though sadly some Jews have bought into the Nazi-like cult of Zionism) and Zionists are not necessarily Jews. It must be reiterated that Judaism is completely distinct from Zionism, the Nazi-like fascist cult, and to conflate the two is deeply antisemitic. Mamdani would do well to make it known that he will not stand for this kind of slander of the Jewish people and that he will do whatever he can with his powers as Mayor to prevent any such attempts to further smear Jewish people with the Zionist label. Mamdani should remind all of New York City that Jews are lovingly welcomed, but the antisemitic Zionists shall not be tolerated.
I wonder what old Bernard’s reaction would have been if Mamdani had responded to him with something like that.
