Thanks for the links. I’ve been reading. It is not far off my understanding. It’s novel to me that anyone claims that the famine itself was deliberate. I’ve never heard anyone claiming that before.

Anyway, I noticed that https://lb.ua/news/2010/01/14/19793_nalivaychenko_nazval_kolichestvo_zh.html says 10 million, while https://hexbear.net/post/20004 links to it and claims it says 4 million. I guess the wayback machine should be checked.

My day was long, I’m tired, and there is more to read. I’ll have to re-read your previous comments to find the Q that interests you.