Heresy, right? I’ve had a mechanical for the last couple of years, and while it’s served me well enough, I still don’t like the feel or clickety-clack compared to a membrane switch - and my current one is the Razer Blackwidow Stealth w/ rubber o-rings added to the base of each key, which I think is as non-clackety as a mechanical gets.

Anyway, the Blackwidow is starting to have issues - F5 key died months ago, and lately it’s been doing this annoying thing where I press a key and it registers the downstroke, but not the release, of the Tab and D keys until I pull it from its USB port and reinsert. It’s time.

…but the initial search for a replacement all I’m seeing are either mechanical or mimicking mechanical (like a membrane switch but with the big blocky keys that mechanicals use).

My favorite keyboard ‘feel’ 100% is an oldschool laptop style keyboard. Like the IBM T60 - flat, light to the touch, and no dead space in between the keys like you see in a lot of today’s laptops (the ‘island’ style… not a fan).

I don’t think my entire wish-list exists in a single product, but what I’m after is:

  • That T60 style described above

  • Programmable keys (remap / macros)

  • Corded… unless cordless options have really improved in the last decade or so: I recall a noticeable delay, and constantly running out of battery.

  • Extra keys specifically for binding macros like the Blackwidow

  • Backlight. Low priority, and I don’t give a shit about RGB (or aesthetics in general), but it is nice to be able to be able to see which key is which when the room is dark.

…is anything even kind-of like that on the market, or should I just shut up and get another mechanical?

  • DominusOfMegadeus@sh.itjust.works
    1·
    3 days ago

    I’m not entirely clear on the layout you want or the feel or travel distance of the key presses you like, but I am reasonably comfortable that this one checks all your boxes.

    https://www.razer.com/gaming-keyboards/razer-ornata-v3-x

    EDIT: I would bet dollars to donuts you would love something along these lines if you swapped out the standard keycaps with low profile ones.

    https://www.keychron.com/collections/keychron-he-keyboards/products/keychron-k4-he-wireless-magnetic-switch-custom-keyboard

    • Sterile_Technique@lemmy.world
      OPEnglish
      2·
      2 days ago

      I would bet dollars to donuts you would love something along these lines if you swapped out the standard keycaps with low profile ones.

      I’ve never even heard of magnetic switches. I’m intrigued! Trying to imagine the feel of spring pushing against a magnet, I think I you’re right: that sounds like it would feel great! I’m going to hit a few local electronics stores to see if I can find one to try out - seems like an endcap-display kind of thing.

      Skimming that second link you posted, I see a few options on the keycaps, but none that say low profile. Would that be a 3rd party purchase thing, or am I overlooking something from Keychron?

      The magnetic switches themselves don’t actually click, right? I pulled up some reviews and it still sounds clicky, but I’m guessing that’s the plastic-on-plastic sound of the keycap hitting the post… so, does the rubber o-ring trick work with these to make it fairly silent?

      The Ornata also looks like a solid choice per my wishlist. I haven’t had great luck with Razer - tbh, part of me’s been looking forward to the Blackwidow finally breaking so I’d have an excuse to be done with them. But… a match is a match!

      Thanks for the feedback!

      • DominusOfMegadeus@sh.itjust.works
        2·
        2 days ago

        These particular switches are not clicky and are fairly silent to be honest. I can speak from experience because I bought one of these and I fucking hate it. But you would love it because it’s the exact kind of key press feel you’re describing. Plus, you can tweak it to be stronger or weaker resistance, depending on whatever mood you’re in frankly. And yes, the key caps would have to be a third-party purchase, but you can find low profile key caps on Amazon and as long as they are cherry compatible, which like 99.9% of key caps are, you’ll be fine. They’ll sit a little higher because than they would on a low profile keyboard because the Hall effect switches on the Keychron are not low profile so the stems are not shorties like you would find on a true low profile, but if you put low profile key caps on them, I don’t think you’ll really care that you know they’re 4 mm higher up from the board plate then a true low profile cap would be. It doesn’t really make a difference in the typing experience and you wouldn’t even notice unless you’re looking really close.